Contact Us

We are located on beautiful Shelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York.Shelter Island Insurance Group

PO Box 539
25 North Ferry Road,
Shelter Island NY 11964

Mobile 1-516-695-8591
Office 1-631-749-1014
FAX 1-631-749-2228

Our Staff

Robert P. Brady
President / Owner
Office: 1-631-749-1014
rbrady@shelterislandinsurance.com

Kate Davidson
Agent/Sales
Office 1-631-749-1014
Mobile 1-631-413-8537
kdavidson@shelterislandinsurance.com

Andrew Brady
Vice-President / Sales
Office: 1-631-749-1014
Mobile: 1-631-241-8204
abrady@shelterislandinsurance.com

Request Quote

Business

Personal